COBRA isn't much help

Workers who are laid off (or worry about being laid off) are pointed to The Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act as the thing that will help them if they lose health care insurance through their jobs.

But a new analysis by The Commonwealth Fund finds that only 9 percent of laid-off workers took up coverage under COBRA in 2006.

Anyone who's compared coverage costs knows that COBRA is expensive. It's a last-ditch alternative for many who can't find less expensive coverage on the open market.

The Commonwealth report says unemployed workers would need a 75 percent to 85 percent subsidy (from where?!) to keep their premium contributions at the levels they paid on the job.

The report, "Maintaining Health Insurance During a Recession: Likely COBRA Eligibility," said that 60 percent of current workers, if laid off, would be eligible for COBRA.

"But for most people, COBRA payments are unaffordable" -- averaging $4,704 a year for individuals and $12,680 for families -- the report said.

Submitted by Diane Stafford on January 23, 2009 - 1:00am.
| | add new comment
Submitted by Anonymous on January 26, 2009 - 4:20pm.

Last time I checked, we already have government sponsored health care. If you cannot afford care, medicare/medicaid is established for assistance. If you go to any hospital in need of care, by law they are unable to refuse service. As for "universal coverage", at what point do you draw the line on service provided? When is it ok to order an MRI or other expensive test? The same people shouting for Universal Care are the one's complaining about HMOs. The government will be worse than any HMO of the past.

Submitted by Anonymous on January 26, 2009 - 11:44am.

The government has no business in health care. Their attempt at it has been the nightmare of Medicare/Medicaid. The COBRA subsidy they are trying to foist on us will ultimately be paid by the taxpayers. Health care is not a right-get the government out of it and costs will go down.

Submitted by Anonymous on January 26, 2009 - 8:35am.

Wow, I certainly agree that we need universal health insurance, but the idea that business has a vested interest in high costs in order to "enslave" workers is absurd. Health care costs are burdensome to businesses and we would all welcome lower premiums.

Submitted by Anonymous on January 23, 2009 - 12:20pm.

Also, these costs are not pre-tax. Secondly, the majority of the Employees taking Cobra are sick and stats show that the actual claims on this group far exceed the premium on this group by as much as 250%. Not a good deal muhabbet for the Employer or the Insurance company.

Submitted by Anonymous on January 23, 2009 - 12:20pm.

The American Recovery and Reinvestment bill now in Congress includes a 65% subsidy for COBRA payments by the unemployed. Let's hope it happens -- no, let's help it happen. Write to your Congressman and Senators now.

See www.unemployedworkers.org

Submitted by Anonymous on January 23, 2009 - 9:51am.

First of all, Cobra shows the cost of the plan +2%. The shock factor is that Employees never realized what their Employer was contributing, so the price seems high. Also, these costs are not pre-tax. Secondly, the majority of the Employees taking Cobra are sick and stats show that the actual claims on this group far exceed the premium on this group by as much as 250%. Not a good deal for the Employer or the Insurance company. The subsidy discussed is the Employer and government pre-tax contribution. DUH! kc

Submitted by Anonymous on January 23, 2009 - 9:01am.

COBRA is a way big business keeps the little people down. You can't leave your job for a better one and afford private insurance. Big business knows that and wants to keep insurance as high as possible so they can enslave their workforce. We need insurance for all.

Submitted by Anonymous on January 23, 2009 - 8:17am.

Sort of tells you all you need to know about government involvement in health care, doesn't it?


User login

Hire Me!

Testing the job market? Dollars & Sense has pulled together some resources to help you through these rough times.

Jobstart

These Companies Are Currently Hiring

Job Clubs

Click here for job transition support groups.

Kansas City Metro Networking Job Club

Job Club link

Dollars & Sense is offering a free forum for job seekers through a partnership with the Kansas City Metro Networking Job Club. Check out job openings, tout your talents and post your resumes. Just register on the networking site and check out the resources.

How I Got the Job

  • Autumn WernerAutumn WernerThe job: Surveillance analyst
    The employer: KeyBank Real Estate Capital, in Kansas City, is a division of Cleveland-based KeyBank. KeyBank Real Estate is a full-service real estate finance organization operating in 32 major U.S. markets in 20 states.


Personal Finance Center


Dollars & Sense TV




Navigation

Free Financial Advice

4/9/09

Question:

BRB asks

Who do I talk to for financial advice that does not involve them trying to sell me something? We are 60 and 59, have a 200,000 annuity, are 60-70,000 credit card debt, have a house that is half paid for,own a condo in fl that is not paying for itself, have a good credit rating, not behind on anything, not facing foreclosure, wife on disability, husband still working, Want to pay off credit cards, but don't know how. Should we use part of annuity? I just want to know who to ask for help. Thanks

Answer:

It looks like you would be well served by a comprehensive financial plan which would address your concerns and give you a clear picture of where you are at financially. Financial advisors are paid in two different ways. Some receive commissions for the products they sell you. There are also fee only financial planners who work for you for a set fee and sell no products. In their case you know exactly how much it will cost you up front. It would also be preferable to use a financial planner who is a Certified Financial Planner.

Best Regards,
G. Douglas Dunham

READ MORE...

Submitted by FPA on April 9, 2009 - 2:00pm.
| 1 comment

Recent comments